HDL cholesterol: Too much of a good thing?

I used to be thrilled that my blood level of HDL cholesterol, the so-called good cholesterol, was high, the likely result of my devotion to daily physical activity. After all, HDL, for high-density lipoprotein, acts like an arterial cleanser, removing cholesterol from blood vessels and preparing it for removal outside the body.

An ample supply of HDL cholesterol in blood serum has long been linked to protection against coronary heart disease and stroke, so what could be bad?

READ: To halve your risk of heart disease, keep moving

I now know that, as with many other good things in life, there can be too much of this usually helpful protein. The best available evidence has shown that most of us would probably be best off aiming for moderation with regard to serum levels of HDL.

A series of studies, large and small, in this country and abroad shows that the relationship of HDL levels to heart disease and overall mortality forms a U-shaped curve: Too little and too much of this blood lipid are, on average, associated with an elevated risk of heart disease, cancer and premature death.

Although cardiologists can still only guess at why very high HDL levels may incur a health risk, the findings reinforce the importance of focusing less on the “good” cholesterol and even more on the “bad” – the level of LDL, or low-density lipoprotein, cholesterol that is still too high in as many as one-third of adults in this country.

READ: Can you miss the signs of heart disease or a heart attack?

These findings, among others, are prompting doctors to rethink their approach to patients who may have an elevated risk of developing a heart attack, stroke or other life-threatening cardiovascular problem.

“High cholesterol treatment is not one-size-fits-all,” Dr C. Michael Valentine, president of the American College of Cardiology, said last month about new guidelines issued by his organisation and the American Heart Association. The guidelines emphasize the importance of personalised care, not cookie-cutter prescriptions based solely on blood test results.

Since the last such guidelines were issued in 2013, Valentine said, “We’ve learned even more about new treatment options and which patients may benefit from them.” Experts have also learned that in most cases, it is not necessary for cholesterol tests to be done only after an overnight fast, which should be a relief for both patients and their doctors.

High cholesterol treatment is not one-size-fits-all

When patients are found to have high cholesterol, the new guidelines state that it is not enough to take only traditional risk factors like smoking and high levels of blood pressure and blood sugar into account in deciding whom to treat and with what.

Everyone with high cholesterol may not need drug therapy to lower this harmful blood fat. In fact, unless LDL levels are astronomically high or the person has known heart disease, treatment should not begin with a drug but with lifestyle: a heart-healthy diet, physical exercise and, if needed, weight loss. Only when these fail to lower cholesterol should drug treatment be considered, the guidelines state.

READ: Vitamin D and fish oils are ineffective for preventing cancer and heart disease

Furthermore, the organisations recommended that in addition to traditional cardiac risk factors, others that should be taken into account include family history, ethnic background and disorders like metabolic syndrome, chronic kidney disease, inflammatory conditions, early menopause and even pregnancy-related high blood pressure.

If a doctor is still uncertain about which patients warrant a drug remedy to lower cholesterol, the new guidelines suggest getting a coronary artery calcium score, obtained via a specialised X-ray scan that measures calcium-containing plaque in the arteries that feed the heart.

START CHOLESTEROL SCREENING EARLY

Nor should people wait until midlife to worry about their risk of heart disease. The new guidelines emphasise that cardiovascular disease develops over the course of a lifetime; an elevated level of cholesterol at any age has a cumulative effect that gradually increases cardiac risk. Accordingly, the guidelines suggest that cholesterol screening in children as young as two is appropriate when there is a family history of heart disease or elevated cholesterol.

For other children, cholesterol measurements might be done between ages nine and 11 and again between 17 and 21, the guidelines suggest. Although there are as yet no specific drug recommendations to treat children and young adults who have high cholesterol, following a heart-healthy lifestyle from early childhood on can lower a person’s lifetime risk of heart disease and stroke.

READ: Too much caffeine may stress the heart, cause anxiety and lead to weight gain

“Having high cholesterol at any age increases that risk significantly,” Dr. Ivor Benjamin, president of the American Heart Association, said. “That’s why it’s so important that even at a young age, people follow a heart-healthy lifestyle and understand and maintain healthy cholesterol levels.”

Which raises the question, “What is a healthy level of both HDL and LDL cholesterol?” The answer depends on your family history and what else might be wrong with you.

Dr. Marc Allard-Ratick of Emory University School of Medicine in Atlanta who studied the link between HDL cholesterol levels and the risk of having a heart attack or dying of cardiovascular disease, told me that having an HDL level between 40 and 60 milligrams per deciliter of blood serum represents the “sweet spot, at the bottom of a U-shaped curve,” where the health risk is lowest.

Having high cholesterol at any age increases the risk of heart disease and stroke significantly

He said having “a very low HDL level – below 30 milligrams – is a marker that you’re not doing well,” and a level above 70 milligrams can be an added risk for people who already have heart disease or an increased likelihood of developing it.

“HDL may not function as well in people who are unhealthy, people with cardiovascular disease,” he said. “HDL is a much more complex marker of cardiovascular disease risk than LDL; we don’t know how helpful or harmful it is long-term.”

Thus, until more is known about how HDL functions at high levels, he and other experts recommend a better-safe-than-sorry approach, avoiding efforts to raise HDL cholesterol with drugs to levels above 60 or 70 milligrams, especially for people already known to have cardiovascular disease.

“In our study of 5,500 high-risk patients, there was a positive association with all-cause mortality in people with HDL levels of 80 or above,” Allard-Ratick said.

However, the level of LDL cholesterol tells a different story. This is the substance that deposits plaque on the walls of arteries, plaque that can eventually precipitate a heart attack or stroke.

“With LDL, there is no sweet spot,” Allard-Ratick said. “The higher it is, the worse you’re doing."

Current recommendations call for LDL cholesterol levels to be under 100 milligrams per deciliter of blood serum for people who are otherwise healthy, and under 70 milligrams for those who already have heart disease or are at high risk of developing it.

Jane E. Brody © The New York Times 2018

Jane Brody is the personal health columnist at The New York Times, a position she has held since 1976. She has written more than a dozen books including the best-sellers “Jane Brody’s Nutrition Book” and “Jane Brody’s Good Food Book.”

READ: Commentary: Add more plants, and less meat to your meals. Here’s why​​​​​​​